Section Head, Pediatric Neurosurgery Cleveland Clinic, United States
Disclosure(s):
Shehryar Sheikh, MD MPH: No financial relationships to disclose
Introduction: Brainstem tumors represent ~10% of pediatric brain tumors, ~80% of these are diffuse intrapontine gliomas (DIPG, primarily WHO Grade 4 midline glioma, H3 K27M-mutant). Given invariably poor prognosis in these cases, there continues to be immense variation (across the US and internationally) in performing biopsy of these lesions as opposed to making a presumptive diagnosis based on MRI. Several multi-center studies in recent years have aimed to show the safety profile of biopsy but an updated meta-analysis is lacking.
Methods: We found 29 studies of pediatric brainstem biopsy in the last 20 years (2003-2023), representing data from 1002 children. We applied meta-analysis of proportions using a random-effects model to generate point estimates, confidence intervals, and measures of heterogeneity.
Results: 87% of procedures were stereotactic needle biopsies (of these, 62% with a frame, 14% without frame, and 24% robotic.) Biopsy yield (i.e. the rate at which biopsy resulted in a tissue diagnosis) was 94% (95% CI 92-97). Temporary complications were seen in 6% (95 CI 4-8), most commonly including 1) radiographic evidence of bleeding or air without an associated fixed neurological deficit, 2)cranial nerve dysfunction, and 3) delayed awakening. Permanent complications (excluding death) were seen in 1% (95% CI 0.5-2), most commonly including cranial nerve dysfunction and limb weakness. 5 deaths were reported in the entire pooled cohort of 1002 children (0.5%). Gliomas represented 92% of tumors (95% CI 89-95). Of the gliomas for which WHO grading was provided, 68% were high grade (III/IV).
Conclusion : When counseling families on the merits of brainstem biopsy in children, it is reasonable to state that permanent morbidity is rare ( < 2%). If biopsy is performed specifically to facilitate enrollment in clinical trials requiring a molecular diagnosis, the risks of biopsy outlined here should be weighed against potential benefits of trial enrollment.
